If you’re a digital marketer, you’ve probably felt the rush of seeing those campaign metrics move in the right direction after a strategic tweak.
It’s addictive, isn’t it?
The thrill of finding that one setting, one audience segment, or one ad placement that gives your numbers a boost. But what happens when that drive to improve becomes, well…. too much?
Over-optimising campaigns is a common mistake in digital marketing. It’s the kind of mistake that often starts with the best intentions but can lead to diminishing returns, wasted effort, and even harm to your overall strategy.
Let’s break down why this happens and how to recognise the signs that you’re optimising too much.
The Problem with Over-Optimising
When we talk about over-optimising, we’re referring to the tendency to make too many adjustments, too frequently, or too granularly. This behaviour can lead to several issues, such as:
Killing the Learning Phase Too Early
Platforms like Meta and Google Ads rely on machine learning to optimise delivery. When you make frequent changes—adjusting budgets, tweaking bids, or swapping out creatives—you reset the learning phase.
The algorithms need time to gather data, understand user behaviour, and optimise for your goals. Constant interruptions prevent this process from completing, leaving your campaigns stuck in a limbo of underperformance.
Example: Suppose you’re running a conversion campaign, and after just two days, you notice the CPA is higher than expected. Panicking, you double down on targeting or change your bidding strategy. Instead of giving the algorithm the time it needs to stabilise, you end up confusing it, causing erratic performance.
Chasing Vanity Metrics
It’s easy to get caught up in improving surface-level metrics like CTR or impressions while ignoring what really matters: conversions, revenue, or customer lifetime value. Over-optimising for these vanity metrics can lead to spending money on clicks that don’t convert or audiences that don’t align with your business goals.
Example: Let’s say you’ve been testing headlines and discover one that increases CTR by 30%. You run with it, only to realise later that it’s attracting the wrong audience—people who click but never purchase.
Over-Segmentation
Audience segmentation is a powerful tool, but overdoing it can lead to fragmented data and higher costs. Breaking audiences into too many small segments often reduces the algorithm’s ability to find efficiencies at scale, which often results in increased CPAs and reduced campaign effectiveness.
Example: Instead of targeting a broader audience for your skincare brand, you create micro-segments like “25-30-year-olds interested in vegan skincare” and “30-35-year-olds interested in dermatologist-recommended products.” While this might seem strategic, the smaller pool limits the algorithm’s ability to optimise efficiently.
Ignoring Big-Picture Goals
Hyper-focusing on individual elements of a campaign can make you lose sight of your overall marketing objectives. Over-optimisation often leads to campaigns being tailored for short-term wins at the expense of long-term growth.
Example: You run daily sales ads and notice that certain audiences perform exceptionally well. You shift all your budget to them, ignoring your broader brand awareness campaigns. While sales spike initially, your top-of-funnel traffic dries up over time, hurting your ability to generate new leads.
Recognising the Signs of Over-Optimisation
How do you know if you’re pushing your campaigns too far? Look out for these red flags:
Frequent Changes: If you’re tweaking your campaigns daily without allowing enough time for results, you’re likely over-optimising.
Overcomplicated Setup: If your campaign structure has too many segments, rules, or manual adjustments, you’re overthinking it.
Performance Decline: Counterintuitively, over-optimisation often leads to worse performance, as campaigns lose the data they need to stabilise and succeed.
How to Avoid Over-Optimising?
The good news? Avoiding over-optimisation doesn’t mean giving up on improving your campaigns. At the end of the day, it’s about finding the right balance between analysis and action. Here’s how:
Set Clear KPIs
Define the metrics that make a difference to your business. Whether it’s ROAS, cost-per-lead, or customer lifetime value, let these guide your decisions rather than vanity metrics.
Follow the 72-Hour Rule
For campaigns that rely on algorithmic learning, avoid making adjustments more frequently than every 72 hours. This gives the platform enough time to stabilize and gather real data.
Test Strategically
Instead of testing everything at once, focus on one variable at a time. For example, test headlines one week, then audience segments the next. Controlled testing allows you to isolate what’s working and what isn’t.
Embrace Broader Targeting
Trust the algorithm’s ability to find efficiencies at scale. Instead of over-segmenting, use broader audiences and let machine learning optimise for your objectives.
Look at the Big Picture
Remember that campaigns are part of a larger strategy. Don’t abandon long-term goals like brand awareness or customer retention for short-term performance gains.
Final Thoughts
Over-optimising campaigns is like over-salting your food—it starts with a pinch here and a pinch there, but before you know it, the dish is ruined.
As digital marketers, it’s our job to strike a balance between improving campaigns and giving them the breathing room they need to succeed. The next time you’re tempted to tinker with your ads for the tenth time in a week, ask yourself: is this change truly necessary, or am I just looking for something to do?
SO, WHERE DO YOU FIND THIS PARTNER?
Well, aren’t we glad you asked! We at DigiCom are obsessive data-driven marketers pulling from multi-disciplinary strategies to unlock scale. We buy media across all platforms and placements and provide creative solutions alongside content creation, and conversion rate optimizations. We pride ourselves on your successes and will stop at nothing to help you grow.
留言